• Slide 1

    Article Details

    Find, consult and hire the best Lawyers in India

MAINTENANCE TO EMPLOYED WIFE - LIABILITY OF HUSBAND

2017-10-23 15:54:21
MAINTENANCE TO EMPLOYED WIFE - LIABILITY OF HUSBAND

Maintenance to Employed Wife

The provision purports to provide relief to a wife who is unable to maintain herself, indicating that in case she is capable of doing that, then she may not successfully claim further payment of maintenance by husband. The provision also contains words “with sufficient means” meaning that the person against whom the proceedings have been initiated must have reasonable means of maintaining the wife but neglects/refuses to do so. Provision under CrPC is not in conflict with the same under personal laws, and a person not entitled to maintenance under this section may still successfully sue under their respective laws. The judicial trend with respect to maintenance to employed wives has been varying over time, and the view has been quite dynamic. It is not necessary that the woman should be an absolute destitute before she can claim maintenance, and the phrase “not able to maintain herself” indicates that she is unable to meet her needs even if she has a meager income.

·         Pratab Bhai Trivedi v Priyamvada Ghamu Pratapbhai Trivedi[1], the Court held that merely because the respondent had chosen to work would not disentitle her to the right of maintenance.

·         Ashok Kumar vs. Satwant Kuar[2], it was held that the husband’s may avail benefit in terms of his liability, to the extent of the independent income of the wife, but then again his income too will be taken into consideration.

·         In Mamta Jaiswal v Rajesh Jaiswal[3], it was held that a spouse who is well qualified to get the service immediately with less efforts is not expected to remain idle and to squeeze out the adversary by implementing the provisions of law suitable to their purpose.

·         The Madras HC in Manokaran @ Ramamoorthy vs M. Devaki[4] held that an employed wife with sufficient means could not receive maintenance under S.24 HMA.

·         Munish Bhasin & Ors v NCT of Delhi and Anr[5], held that it was not open to the Court to direct the appellant to pay maintenance to his wife and child as a pre-condition foe anticipatory bail u/s 498A or S.406 IPC.

·         Neeraj Aggarwal v veeka Aggarwal[6], it was held that in the present case the applicant/ wife is a well-qualified engineer and, therefore, there is no need for her to sit idle at home waiting for the maintenance from the husband.

However, it has to be noted that this is not a blanket refusal by the judiciary to provide maintenance to employed wives. The Supreme Court has laid down that an estranged woman can claim maintenance from her husband in spite of her efforts to earn a monthly income if that is not enough for her maintenance, and she does not need to be an absolute destitute to apply for maintenance.



INDIAN KANOON

[1] II (1993) DMC 25 Gujarat

[2]  I (1983) DMC 27 Delhi

[3] Civil Revision No. 1290/99 Decided On: 24.03.2000, HC of Madhya Pradesh

[4] AIR 2003 Mad 212

[5] CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 344 OF 2009 before the SC of India

[6] M No. 28/07, ADDL. DISTRICT JUDGE, Rohini, New Delhi

LEGAL REMEDIES FOR PROPERTY DISPUTES

LEGAL REMEDIES FOR PROPERTY DISPUTES

13 February 2018   03 09 PM
Read More
Is builder reputation important for investing in real estate?

Is builder reputation important for investing in real estate?

30 January 2018   05 26 PM
Read More
REMEDIES FOR DELAYED POSSESSION UNDER RERA - Legal Resolved

REMEDIES FOR DELAYED POSSESSION UNDER RERA - Legal Resolved

27 January 2018   11 48 AM
Read More
What is the best way to handle cheating partner?

What is the best way to handle cheating partner?

25 January 2018   12 09 PM
Read More
HOW A LAWYER CAN HELP TO RESOLVE BUILDER DISPUTES?

HOW A LAWYER CAN HELP TO RESOLVE BUILDER DISPUTES?

23 January 2018   05 07 PM
Read More
BUILDER DISPUTE- NCDRC OR RERA?

BUILDER DISPUTE- NCDRC OR RERA?

16 January 2018   01 41 PM
Read More
Importance of filing a Legal Notice in India - Legal Resolved

Importance of filing a Legal Notice in India - Legal Resolved

09 January 2018   05 15 PM
Read More